4 pointsClass 4Question 6
Ria says: I am thinking of a shape that has 4 sides. Sam may ask questions to work out exactly which shape it is. Which of these questions would be LEAST useful to Sam?
Show the answer and how to see it
Answer: Does it have 4 sides?
A useful question is one whose answer could still go either way. Ria has already said the shape has 4 sides, so asking that again is certain to get yes and rules nothing out. The other questions all split the four-sided shapes into two groups.
Why a child picks Are all 4 of its sides the same length?: This one helps: a square and a rhombus say yes, a rectangle and a kite say no.
Sit the whole paper this came from4 pointsClass 7Question 1
A park has five gates: A, B, C, D and E. Paths join A to B, A to C, B to C, B to D, C to D, C to E, and D to E. A sweeper wants to sweep every path exactly once, never going along the same path twice. From how many of the five gates could she START and still manage it?
Show the answer and how to see it
Answer: 2
Count the paths meeting at each gate. Every gate she passes THROUGH uses up two paths, one in and one out, so a gate with an odd number of paths can only be where she starts or where she finishes. Exactly two gates here have an odd number.
Why a child picks 5: Every gate is reachable from every other, but being connected is not enough. Where she starts still matters.
Sit the whole paper this came from