🚌1. Everyone’s doing it
Bandwagon
Saying something is right or true because lots of people do it or believe it.
“Everyone in my class has the new game, so it must be the best game ever.”
Say back: Lots of people can be wrong. What’s the reason it’s good?
👉2. Attack the person
Ad hominem
Attacking the person who made the argument instead of the argument itself.
“Don’t listen to Sam’s idea for the class trip. He can’t even tie his shoes.”
Say back: Sam’s shoes don’t change whether the idea is good. What about the idea?
🧑🌾3. Twist their words
Straw man
Changing someone’s argument into a sillier one, then knocking that down.
Mia: “We should have less homework.” Leo: “So you think we should never learn anything?”
Say back: That’s not what I said. I said less homework, not no learning.
🔀4. Only two options
False choice
Pretending there are only two choices when there are more.
“Either you’re on the soccer team or you don’t care about our school.”
Say back: There are lots of ways to care about the school.
🛝5. One step to disaster
Slippery slope
Claiming one small step will lead to a chain of terrible things, without showing why.
“If we let kids have five more minutes of recess, soon they’ll want recess all day and nobody will learn to read.”
Say back: Why would five minutes lead to all that? Each step needs a reason.
🏃6. Too few examples
Hasty generalization
Making a big rule from just one or two examples.
“I met two rude kids from Oak School. Everyone at Oak School is rude.”
Say back: Two kids aren’t the whole school. How many did you meet?
🍒7. Only the good bits
Cherry picking
Showing only the facts that help your side and hiding the rest.
“Our team won 3 games this month!” (They lost 9.)
Say back: What about all the games, not just the wins?
🎓8. Trust me, I’m famous
Wrong expert
Trusting someone about a topic outside what they know. (Real experts on their own topic are worth listening to.)
“A famous basketball player says this cereal makes you smarter, so it must.”
Say back: Is a basketball player an expert on brains? What does the evidence say?
⏱️9. It came first, so it caused it
After this, so because of this
Thinking that because one thing happened before another, it caused it.
“I wore my lucky socks and we won. The socks made us win!”
Say back: Would we have won without them? Let’s test it more than once.
🔄10. Going in circles
Circular reasoning
Using the claim itself as the reason for the claim.
“This is the best book because it’s better than all the other books.”
Say back: That just says it again. What makes it the best?
🐟11. Change the subject
Red herring
Bringing up something unrelated to pull attention away from the real question.
Mom: “Did you finish your homework?” Kid: “Did you know octopuses have three hearts?”
Say back: Cool fact! But back to the question: is the homework done?
🥺12. Feel it, don’t think it
Appeal to feelings
Using strong feelings like fear or pity in place of reasons.
“If you don’t buy me this toy, I’ll be sad forever and it’ll be your fault.”
Say back: Feelings matter, but they aren’t a reason on their own. What are the reasons?